Sunday, November 15, 2026

The Brightness (4*)

 


I'll say this for Chad Harbach:  he's got balls as big as his expansive talent. Several young women on voyages of self-discovery populate his long-gestating second novel, which includes several characters from The Art of Fielding, his much-beloved breakout first, one of whom is gay and black.  Isn't this verboten territory for a straight, middle-aged white guy nowadays?

No doubt Harbach will point to classics of literature as his defense and, for the most part, I would agree:  the quality of the work matters more than the gender or race of the author. And in The Brightness, he's certainly tackling a subject as compelling as it is contemporary: rape culture on American campuses as seen from a whatever-wave-we're-calling-it-now feminist perspective.

At least that's how it appears in this lengthy, meandering novel's early chapters. Three undergraduates at Westish College (also the setting for The Art of Fielding) hatch an entirely believable plot to shake up the "Parties," a traditional fraternity event that kicks off the fall semester.  Two unsuspecting bros, one good, one bad, wake up with RAPE VICTIM tattooed on their foreheads. In Tolstoyan fashion, Harbach shunts aside Pammy and her victim, who fall in love; he's more interested in Irma, a star pupil, and Dahlia, her bewitching but flaky friend. They're an intellectual and an activist in a symbiotic relationship although Dahlia, despite her charisma, remains a cipher until she finally speaks her all-too-ordinary truth. 

But it soon turns out that the slightly older, very much adrift Pella Affenlicht is Harbach's primary focus in a fascinating, very metafictional twist.  She inspired another Pella (Affenlight), a vivid character in The Art of Fielding, here written by Owen Dunne, also a character from the previous book and now the gay, black stand-in for Harbach. Got it?  Or do I need to add that "licht" is German for light and remind you that the title of his new book is The Brightness, also the name of a mostly online feminist enterprise enthralled by Dahlia's and Irma's prank?  Harbach is nothing if not clever in his wordplay and meticulous plotting, particularly in a chapter that features buckets of menstrual blood that seems gratuitous until it's not.  He's also extraordinarily good at describing the interactions of people with their pets, destination weddings and the exuberance of dancing, if not the division of labor in a vacation house, at least in my experience:

All this preparatory labor, the foraging and lugging and fire-building, the trips up and down the ladder, sobered them up in a gentle, salubrious way, so when they reconvened around the orange and crackling fire, they looked cheerful and revivified, suffused with a vacation-house sense of shared and successful industry.

Pella, the still insecure but now-engaged daughter of the closeted Westish dean with whom Owen, a baseball jock, had an affair, have bonded since her father's death. She's about to travel to Block Island (where the second third of the novel takes place) to serve as his maid of honor. Their relationship, forged during sleepless nights of grieving e-mail correspondence, has contributed significantly to the genesis of The Art of Fielding, but Pella believes her keen editorial eye more than helped transform Owen's first draft into a best seller blessed by the critical establishment. She looks forward to his wedding as a kind of coming out party, giving her the opportunity to hob nob with the literati. Meeting her father's favorite author reminds Pella that she once wanted to write, too. He tells her that writing is nothing more than transferring your thoughts to paper ("Everybody’s got something, but nobody wants to sit down and do the goddamn work.").

I initially thought this might be Harbach's way of acknowledging another actual woman's contributions to his success but he has something both more pedestrian and profound on his mind.  Pella, a born caretaker, discovers you can go home again, even after she has the best sex of her life in New York with the son of a first-wave feminist artist whose conflicted creativity the author convincingly imagines.  Even if The Brightness doesn't quite rise to the level of The Art of Fielding, Harbach nevertheless hits the ball out of the park with this passage which superbly articulates the ecstatic pleasures of reading, particularly when sex feels like a distant memory.

Nicholas possessed within him a vigilance, an almost obsessive requirement for honesty, a talent for steering against falseness. He combined this with a talent for praising her, and the combination felt maniacally satisfying, because it meant that the praise was true. Was it silly to say that something of the heightened glory of her favorite books, the religiosity of literature, was what she felt when they were naked together? There were passages in Jane Austen, in Tolstoy, in Wharton, in James—and so on, they weren’t all dead, the writers who could do this to her—that described Pella’s internal states of being with such clarity and accuracy that the corresponding instantaneous rearrangement and refinement of her own perception amounted to a brand-new internal state, so that having certain fleeting, hard-to-capture states of consciousness described by a person outside herself amounted, inside herself, to a brand-new state of consciousness; so that the pleasure—no, the religious nature of reading derived equally from the accurate description of her consciousness as it existed and the emergence therefrom of a consciousness that was new; and this was what it felt like when they had sex.


No comments:

Post a Comment