Showing posts with label Vasari. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Vasari. Show all posts

Saturday, October 4, 2025

The Brunelleschi Dome

If not for the Catholic church, it might have been known as the Brunelleschi Dome, like the Eiffel Tower.
 

It dominates the city's skyline in the same unmistakable way.


Filippo Brunelleschi had a lot more going for him than Eiffel, in spite of the latter's world-wide name recognition.  He's considered the father of Renaissance architecture, he supervised the construction of the Duomo di Firenze and he secured the first patent in history, among other accomplishments.

It's hard to get an unobstructed view of Brunelleschi's masterwork, an unimpeachable example of how workarounds can inspire creativity: design competitors were forbidden from using buttresses.  The resulting Duomo cleanly broke with the Gothic era.



Construction of the Cathedral of St. Mary the Flower (its formal name) began more than a century before Brunelleschi, with the backing of the Medici family, won the dome design competition but didn't assume sole responsibility for the project until three years later, in 1423.  Giotto had designed the campanile nearby before his death in 1334. 


I resisted the temptation to climb to the top of the campanile knowing that my knees would howl on the way down.


Emilio De Fabris didn't design the facade until the late 19th century.



His use of polychrome marble makes the Duomo even more distinctive IMHO.  It's also neo-Gothic, meaning the architecture has almost come full circle since 1296 when the first papal representative ever sent to Florence from Rome laid the initial brick.




Interior

The cathedral presents as surprisingly empty when you enter, perhaps because of the vastness of the space and the relocation of much of the art to the adjacent museum.


A number of artists--most notably Giorgio Vasari who painted scenes from "The Last Judgment" around the bottom perimeter--contributed to the dome's interior


This liturgical clock--set to "Italian time" with 24 hours ending at sunset, a standard used until the 18th century--still works, 582 years after its installation. 


Trompe-l'Oeil of Niccolò da Tolentino Andrea del Castagno
Michelangelo, who had been contracted to sculpt the twelve apostles for the Dumo's interior, left Florence after almost finishing only Saint Matthew, who now stands in the Accademia, keeping an eye on the artist's most famous creation.  I haven't been able to identify this apostle, or his sculptor.


Santa Reparta

My ticket included admission to the Santa Reparta Cathedral buried below the Duomo, built early in the fifth century when the city's population was much smaller.  Little of what remains can be definitively dated, although the discovery of Roman coins has helped refine hypotheses.



Archeologists believe that Christian worshippers trod on this mosaic, which recalls the motifs favored during the Roman Empire, as early as the fourth century.  


These bronze spurs belonged to a knight and early member of the Medici dynasty who served as the Gonfaloniere (magistrate) of Justice for Florence from 1351 to 1352, the year of his death and burial in Santa Reparta.  His tomb wasn't discovered until an excavation of the area that began in 1965 and lasted nearly a decade. 


The Baptistry

I didn't do justice to the Baptistry, perhaps because I never have been baptized.


Modeled on the Pantheon in Rome, it was undergoing renovation in any case, as were many of the sites I visited.


Dante's parents carried their child through its bronze doors one morning for the ceremony. In The Divine Comedy, he expresses his unrealized hope to return to his baptismal font wearing the laurel crown of a poet. 


The Duomo did him one better; when the facade was completed, it included his image as "il Sommo Poeta," or Supreme Poet.  For once, he's not scowling.
 
Dante Aligheri by Cesare Fantacchiotti
(plaster model, 1882-87)


Opera del Duomo Museum

No wonder the Duomo itself looked so barren.  Much of the good stuff is displayed here.

Like Dante (and da Vinci, too) Brunelleschi gazes out from the facade, thoughtfully.

Filippo Brunelleschi by Cesare Fantacchiotti 
(plaster model, 1882-87) 
A pristine model of his dome dominates one gallery


. . . where some of the rudimentary tools used by his construction crew also are on display.


The terrace on top of the museum offers a close-up view of the dome, just across the piazza.


You couldn't ask for a more beautifully designed museum, completely renovated a decade ago, although I found the layout quite confusing.


"Mary in Majesty" by Arnolfo di Cambio (1300-05) & Backrest of Mary's Throne (1295-1305)
The work of Donatello, including this magnificent singing gallery (1433-39), is well-represented in the collection.


These are among 24 bas reliefs figures that Baccio Bandinelli and Giovanni dell' Opera sculpted for the church's choir.  Nudity's juxtaposition startles in between the robed men.



The "Sacrifice of Isaac" by Donatello and Nanni di Bartolo (1421) once adorned the campanile.  The sculptors capture the tense moment a father is spared the anguish of slashing his son's throat through the intervention of an unseen angel, a story that upset me in Bible School which I briefly attended in Heidelberg, mostly for the reward of a block of vanilla ice cream at the end of each class.  It also made me extremely skeptical of loyalty tests.



Many of the small marble reliefs carved for the exterior of the campanile depict non-religious scenes and mythological figures, a welcome--and surprising--respite from all the Christian iconography. 

"Plato & Aristotle: Dialectics"
by Luca della Robbia (1437-39)
"Daedalus: The Mechanical Arts"
by Andrea Pisano (partial, 1348-50)
Donatello's "Penitent Magdalena," carved from white poplar wood, looks like nothing else on display.   Here's what Vasari had to say about her in his Lives of the Artists:  "she has wasted away by fasting and abstinence to such an extent that every part of her body reflects a perfect and complete understanding of human anatomy."  That, and she looks like a contemporary meth head, too!


Michelangelo began sculpting "The Deposition"--also known as the Florentine PietĂ --at the age of 72 (!), using his own face as the model for the man in the hoodie, whose identity has been much debated. The artist, naturally legacy-conscious, worked on what was to be part of his tomb for eight years before attempting to destroy the statue for unknown reasons, although some historians have speculated that he was frustrated to realize the block of marble wasn't large enough to do what he envisioned.  After Michelangelo sold it instead, the new owner had an apprentice sculptor finish the job, minus Christ's left leg. "The Deposition" eventually ended up in the Duomo.



Christ by Florentine Artist (Early 16th Century)
A video display afford's a close-up look at the Duomo's stained glass.


Nothing in the museum impressed me more than this silver altar illustrating scenes from the life of Saint John the Baptist.  Begun in 1367, it took more than a century to complete and was used for special occasions in the Baptistry.  An opportunity to get baptized on it as an adult might be an even bigger incentive than getting into heaven.


You don't often see Saint John's head on a platter in three dimensions!


I đź’— reliquaries, too.
Reliquary by Pasquino da Montepulciano (1470-80)
Reliquary of St. Jerome by
Antonio di Salvi (1487)

Thursday, October 2, 2025

My Renaissance Playlist

Missing it would be like not seeing the "Mona Lisa" on a trip to Paris," but no timed admissions were available at Florence's Accademia when I booked my trip.  Instead, immediately after checking into my hotel, just around the corner, I joined a late-afternoon line and ended up doing a good deed. After eavesdropping on two women ahead of me negotiate with a sketchy guy who was selling timed admission tickets for nearly triple the cost, I said "You sure are trusting."  They took my meaning and within half-an-hour thanked me again as I stood inside the museum, awestruck, gazing up at Michelangelo's "David." As Chris would say, "check."


David's pedestal made it a lot easier to appreciate him than art hanging on the walls. Jockeying for decent sight lines is endemic to the city's must-see venues.  If it's listed in a guidebook, expect crowds.  Herewith a sampling of my favorite works, including several that anticipate the Renaissance about to come.

"Madonna & Child" by
Florentine Painter (13th century)
"Tree of Life" by Pacino di Bonaguida (ca 1310-15)
"The Translation of the Body of Saint Zenobius" 
by Ridolfo del Ghirlandaio (1516-17)
"Annunciation" by Alessandro Allori (1603)
I picked up some new descriptive terminology for altarpieces, too, including "pinnacle" and "predella."  Would you believe that Giorgio Vasari, whose indelible re-acquaintance I made in Venice's Accademia, described this artist as a "minor master"?

"Coronation of the Virgin with four Musical Angels and Saints Francis, John the Baptist, Ivo 
and Dominic" by Giovanni dal Ponte (ca 1430)
Giorgio, I beg to differ.  Just look at these gorgeous details, although the Virgin's finger is a little long.



Saint Jerome &  Saint Julian
by Niccolò di Pietro Gerini
 (1400-05)
I did have a timed admission to the Uffizi Gallery the next morning.  It dwarfs the Accademia.


Statues standing in front depict several icons of Italian culture, all male, of course.


Thanks to Columbia's core curriculum, I had to read two of them.



I'm standing on the gallery's outdoor terrace with the Palazzo Vecchio behind me.  Cosimo I de' Medici commissioned Vasari to design the U-shaped Uffizi ("offices" in Italian) in the mid-16th century as a kind of one-stop shopping for doing business in the duchy of Tuscany which he ruled with an iron fist and a fortune large enough to become one of era's greatest patrons.  His son began displaying the family's treasures on the ground floor and by the next century, everyone taking a Grand Tour of Europe stopped to see the same Renaissance masterpieces that have now been on view for nearly 400 years, 

The Arno River flows west below the gallery's U-bottom.  According to a novel I read after returning, the water once ran red because butchers used it to dispose of blood drained from slaughtered livestock.

Classical Greek and Roman statues are paired with portraits of members of the Medici family including Cosimo I, the big cheese.  

"Statue of a Woman Sacrificing" (Renaissance Copy of Classical Greek Statue) 
Cosimo I de' Medici by Giovanni Battista Naldini (1585)
Alessandro Allori painted mini-frescoes on the corridor ceilings.


Many of the classical statues on display were repaired or copied by Renaissance sculptors.

"Hercules Slaying the Centaur Nessus" 
There's a rogue's gallery of infamous Roman emperors, too.  Medusa adorns Nero's breastplate.



This may or may not be Caligula, according to the curators.  Here's as good a place as any to complain about the Uffizi's lack of consistency in identifying art works. 


Fun fact, overheard from an Aussie tour guide:  Bernardo Buontalenti, the man who designed the Tribuna, where the Medici's displayed their most prized treasures, also invented gelato!  Come to think of it,  the Pines Pantry stocked Talenti which I always thought was an odd name for an ice cream brand.  There must be a connection.


I've only just now reached the conclusion that painting during the Renaissance, in terms of market influence, was just like painting today, except that rich individuals had more say in the subjects chosen, with an emphasis on piety.  Yep, Jesus, virgins, saints and angels were all once the rage less because of devout Christianity than as a hedge against going to Hell. I'm partial to the ones steeped in a little more imagination or idiosyncratic ability.

"Virgin & Child with Angels"
by Piero di Lorenzo del Pratese (1459)
"Adoration of the Christ Child with the Young St. John the Baptist, St. Romuald, Angels,
the Hands of God the Father and the Holy Ghost as a Dove" by Filippo Lipp (ca 1463)
Botticelli really, really sends me, even more than da Vinci and Michelangelo.  Henry James, author of Portrait of a Lady, my favorite novel, may have stood in exactly the same spot as I did marveling at Venus's modesty, although his actual experience of the gallery was vastly different than mine based on what he wrote in Italian Hours: "Sometimes there were not more than two or three figures standing there, Baedeker in hand, to break the charming perspective." Multiply those numbers by a hundred for these paintings.

"The Birth of Venus" by Botticelli (ca 1485)
"Annunciation" by Botticelli (ca 1489-90)
"Calumny of Apelles" by Botticelli (1497)

"Crucifixion" by Agnolo Gaddi (ca 1390-96)
These young Korean women, dressed to kill, sparked an pop cultural epiphany:  Florence was to Renaissance painting what Seoul is to K-Pop.  But will people still be listening to BTS and Blackpink in 2425?


"Madonna and Child with Saint Francis, Saint John the Baptist, Saint Zenobius 
and Saint Lucy" by Domenico Veneziano (ca 1445-47)
"The Penitent St. Jerome" by Filippino Lippi (1493-95)
"Annunciation" by Leonardo da Vinci (ca 1472-75)
Like most artists of the time, da Vinci apprenticed in a workshop.  He painted what I'm guessing was only a small part of this awkward composition with his master.

"The Baptismi of Christ" by Andrea del Verrocchio & Leonardo da Vinci (ca 1475)
Does this sitter remind you of anyone else?  Her family's palace, which turned out to be the anti-Uffizi, was on my itinerary for the next day.

Portrait of Maddalena Strozzi by Raphael (ca 1504-06)
Apart from the ceiling of the Sistine Chapel (photos weren't permitted during my 2001 visit), I'm not that familiar with Michelangelo's painting.  He also designed the frame for this lush, assured work.

"Holy Family with the Young St. John the Baptist 'Doni Tondo'" (ca 1505-07)
Classical Roman Sculpture, Niobe Room
"Saint Jerome in the Desert" by Bellini (ca 1480)
"Madonna with Child" by Giovanni di Franco di Piero (1454-59)
"The Dream" by Alessandro Allori (ca 1570-75)
"Christ Carrying the Cross" by Francesco Salviati (ca 1547)
A 2021 exhibit at the Met turned me on to Bronzino although I prefer his portraits. 

"Allegory of Public Happiness" by Bronzino (ca 1567-68)
"Portrait of Bia de' Medici" by Bronzino (ca 1542)
Did Vasari ever sleep?

"Vulcan's Forge" by Giorgio Vasari (1563-65)
This artist--the same guy who painted the Uffizi's corridor ceilings--came out of Bronzino's workshop.

"Venus & Cupid" by Alessandro Allori (ca 1570)
Endless mobs of people in a small gallery prevented me from getting  decent shot of this "Medusa" (1597) by Caravaggio, a trail blazer of Baroque painting.  I could hardly blame them, however; it's bloody insane!

The Roman god of wine looks too young to drink!

Bacchus by Caravaggio (ca 1595-97)

More Northern Italy